Solid & Engineered

Solid vs. Engineered Wood Flooring: Complete Comparison

Both solid hardwood and engineered wood flooring offer beautiful, natural wood aesthetics, but they differ substantially in structure, performance, and application. Here’s a comprehensive comparison to help you make an informed decision:

Structure & Composition

Solid Hardwood:

  • Made from a single piece of hardwood, typically 3/4″ thick
  • Milled from a single solid piece of lumber
  • 100% natural wood throughout

Engineered Hardwood:

  • Consists of multiple layers: real wood veneer on top (typically 1/16″ to 3/16″ thick) bonded to multiple layers of plywood, HDF, or other wood substrate beneath
  • Cross-layered construction provides dimensional stability
  • Only the top layer is visible hardwood species

Durability & Longevity

Solid Hardwood:
  • Can last 100+ years with proper care
  • Can be refinished multiple times (typically 5-7 times)
  • More susceptible to environmental changes (humidity, temperature)
  • Better suited for above-grade installations
Engineered Hardwood:
  • Typical lifespan of 20-40 years depending on quality
  • Limited refinishing (0-5 times depending on wear layer thickness)
  • Greater resistance to environmental changes
  • Can be installed in more varied locations including below grade

Installation

Solid Hardwood:

  • Typically nail-down or staple-down installation
  • Requires wood subfloor
  • More labor-intensive installation
  • Needs acclimation period (3-7 days)

Engineered Hardwood:

  • Multiple installation methods: float, glue-down, nail-down
  • Can be installed over concrete subfloors
  • DIY-friendly options available
  • Shorter acclimation period (1-3 days)

Moisture & Environment Tolerance

Solid Hardwood:

  • High susceptibility to expansion/contraction
  • Not recommended for bathrooms, basements, or over radiant heating
  • Performs best in climate-controlled environments with stable humidity

Engineered Hardwood:

  • Superior dimensional stability
  • Can be installed in basements and over radiant heating systems
  • Better tolerance for humidity fluctuations
  • Some products suitable for bathrooms with proper installation

Cost Considerations

Solid Hardwood:

  • Cost per square foot varies for materials
  • Higher installation costs ($3-$8 per square foot)
  • Higher long-term value due to refinishing potential

Engineered Hardwood:

  • There is a lower cost per square foot since less material is required
  • Lower installation costs ($3-$5 per square foot)
  • Wide price range depending on veneer thickness and quality

Environmental Impact

Solid Hardwood:

  • Uses more wood resources per square foot
  • Sustainable if sourced from properly managed forests
  • Longer lifespan reduces replacement frequency

Engineered Hardwood:

  • Uses less premium hardwood per square foot
  • Core layers often utilize fast-growing species or wood byproducts
  • Manufacturing process requires adhesives and energy

Resale Value

Solid Hardwood:

  • Traditionally higher resale value
  • Viewed as premium flooring by real estate markets
  • Authentic natural material appeal

Engineered Hardwood:

  • Increasing acceptance in premium market segments
  • Higher-end products with thick veneer layers approaching solid wood in perceived value
  • Practical advantages can be selling points

Best Applications

Solid Hardwood:

  • Main living areas above grade
  • Bedrooms
  • Dining rooms
  • Traditional or historic homes
  • Areas with stable climate conditions

Engineered Hardwood:

  • Basements (with proper moisture barriers)
  • Over concrete slabs
  • Over radiant heating systems
  • Areas with humidity fluctuations
  • Wider installation flexibility throughout the home

This comparison should help you evaluate which type of wood flooring best suits your specific needs, budget, and installation environment.

Scroll to Top